The Viral 'Coquette' Heart Cake (No Heart Pan Needed!)

COOKBOOK

That $80 bakery cake? You’re about to make it for $15.

If you’ve been scrolling through Pinterest or TikTok lately, you’ve seen them — those outrageously gorgeous vintage heart cakes covered in ruffles, swags, and maraschino cherries that scream “Galentine’s brunch” and “Coquette aesthetic.” They look like they require a pastry degree and a $40 specialty heart pan.

Plot twist: You need neither.

This DIY Vintage Lambeth Heart Cake uses a simple round cake pan and a brilliant cutting trick to create that perfect heart shape. And here’s the secret nobody tells you — that “over-the-top” ruffle piping is actually EASIER than smooth frosting because it hides every mistake under layers of maximalist charm.

Let’s break down how to fake professional bakery skills in your kitchen.

⏱ Time Breakdown

  • Baking: 1 hour (includes cooling)

  • Decorating: 1 hour

  • Total: 2 hours from zero to Instagram-worthy

🛒 The Smart Grocery List

The Cake:

  • 1 box Red Velvet or Vanilla Cake Mix (Hack: Replace water with whole milk and oil with melted butter — instant upgrade)

  • Eggs (as directed on box)

The Swiss Meringue Buttercream:

  • 5 large egg whites

  • 1 cup granulated sugar

  • 1Âœ cups (3 sticks) unsalted butter, room temperature

  • 1 tsp vanilla extract

  • Pink gel food coloring + 1 tiny drop brown gel coloring (for that muted vintage pink)

The Vintage Finishing Touches:

  • Maraschino cherries with stems (6–8 cherries)

  • Edible glitter spray (optional but chic)

The Piping Arsenal:

  • Wilton 1M Star Tip (for ruffles and shells)

  • Wilton 70 Leaf Tip (for swags and borders)

  • 2 piping bags

  • Offset spatula

💰 Why This Cake is a Power Move

Bakery VersionYour Version$75-$90$15-$183-day advance orderMade in 2 hours”Bakery secret” techniquesYou now know them

Buttercream Bonus: Swiss Meringue Buttercream doesn’t melt at room temperature like American buttercream. It holds sharp ruffles for hours, even at a party.

Dietary Win: Naturally nut-free (just confirm your cake mix brand).

🎂 Step-by-Step: From Zero to Viral

STEP 1: The Heart Hack (No Special Pan Required)

Bake two 8-inch round cakes according to package directions (use the milk + butter swap). Let cool completely.

The Cutting Method:

  1. Place one round cake on your serving board.

  2. Cut the second cake in half vertically (you now have 2 semi-circles).

  3. Flip each semi-circle cut-side down and position them at the top corners of the full round cake, creating the two bumps of the heart.

  4. Trim the bottom point of the round cake to create a V-shape.

  5. Use small dabs of frosting to “glue” the pieces together.

Pro Tip: Freeze the assembled heart for 15 minutes before crumb coating — it prevents shifting.

STEP 2: The Crumb Coat (Non-Negotiable)

This is where most people fail with red velvet cakes. Those red crumbs will bleed into white frosting if you skip this.

How to Crumb Coat:

  1. Make your Swiss Meringue Buttercream (see recipe below).

  2. Apply a thin layer of frosting over the entire cake with an offset spatula.

  3. Refrigerate for 30 minutes minimum. The frosting should feel firm to touch.

Why It Works: This seals in the crumbs. Your final frosting layer will stay pristine white (or pastel pink).

STEP 3: Swiss Meringue Buttercream Recipe

This is the secret weapon. It pipes like a dream and tastes like silk.

Instructions:

  1. Whisk egg whites and sugar in a heatproof bowl over simmering water until sugar dissolves (160°F or feels smooth between fingers).

  2. Transfer to stand mixer. Whip on high until stiff, glossy peaks form and bowl is cool (8–10 minutes).

  3. Reduce speed to medium. Add butter one tablespoon at a time.

  4. If it looks curdled, keep mixing — it will come together into silky buttercream.

  5. Add vanilla and coloring. For vintage pink: Start with pink gel, add a tiny drop of brown to mute the neon.

Yield: Enough to frost and decorate one heart cake.

STEP 4: The Piping Strategy (Lambeth 101)

Here’s the magic: Lambeth-style piping is all about layering. You’re not aiming for perfection — you’re aiming for abundance.

The Order:

  1. Bottom Shell Border: Use the 1M star tip. Pipe overlapping shells around the entire base. This grounds the cake.

  2. Side Swags: Switch to the leaf tip (70). Pipe upside-down U-shapes (swags) around the sides, spacing them evenly. They should drape like curtains.

  3. Top Border (Double Ruffle): Back to the 1M star tip. Pipe a row of ruffles around the top edge. Then pipe a second row on top of the first for dramatic height.

The “Messy is Vintage” Rule: If your hand shakes or a ruffle looks wonky, just pipe another ruffle next to it. Maximalism forgives all sins.

STEP 5: The Center Message

Use a small round tip to pipe a message:

  • Classic: “Be Mine”

  • Sassy: “XOXO”

  • Galentine’s: “Girls Girls Girls”

OR skip the words and arrange maraschino cherries in a heart pattern in the center.

STEP 6: The Finishing Sparkle

Hold edible glitter spray 12 inches away and mist lightly over the entire cake. This catches light in photos and gives that “professional bakery” shimmer.

🚹 Troubleshooting (Stolen from r/Baking Rants)

“My hand shakes too much to pipe!”

Perfect! The vintage Lambeth style loves organic, slightly messy ruffles. If a line wobbles, just add three more ruffles around it. The aesthetic is maximalist — more is more.

“The red velvet bled into my white frosting!”

You either:

  • Skipped the crumb coat, or

  • Didn’t refrigerate the crumb coat long enough (needs 30 min minimum)

Fix: Next time, chill that crumb coat until it’s firm. The cold frosting acts as a barrier.

“How do I get that muted vintage pink color?”

Stop using straight pink gel coloring — it looks neon. Here’s the secret:

  • Start with a base of pink gel

  • Add one tiny drop of brown gel coloring

  • Mix thoroughly

The brown mutes the brightness into that soft, dusty “Coquette” pink you see on viral cakes.

🎀 Why This Cake Goes Viral

✅ It photographs like a dream (high contrast, texture, height)
✅ It taps into TWO trends (Coquette aesthetic + Galentine’s Day)
✅ It looks harder than it is (People will think you trained at Le Cordon Bleu)
✅ It’s a conversation starter (“Wait, you MADE this?!”)

The Bottom Line

You don’t need a heart-shaped pan. You don’t need steady hands. You don’t need pastry school.

You need two round cakes, a good buttercream, and the confidence to pipe like nobody’s watching.

That $80 bakery cake? You just made it for the price of a latte and a cake mix.

Now go forth and ruffle with reckless abandon. The Coquette era is waiting. 💕

Pin this, tag a Galentine, and show me your chaotic-beautiful heart cakes. Messy ruffles welcome.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Cook it before it’s trending